For Yacht Builders, Buyers, and Owners

For Yacht Builders, Buyers, and Owners

Bayesian Disaster Update: Italian Prosecutor Seeking to Scapegoat Captain and Crew Member

Italy’s official government Prosecutor sides with powerful establishment interests, seeks to pin responsibility for the tragic loss solely upon the captain and crew ...

Phil Friedman's avatar
Phil Friedman
Nov 21, 2026
AI-Edited Image

More than two years ago, in the early morning hours of August 19, 2024, the 180’ sailing yacht Bayesian went down whilst anchored off the coast of Sicily. The sinking appeared to be the result of a waterspout (a waterborne tornado) running the vessel down as her passengers slept and her crew was on deck battening down against a violent storm that had moved in quickly and unexpectedly. Tragically, several lives were lost when the yacht was knocked down onto her beam ends, flooded rapidly, and foundered in a matter of minutes.

In the first couple of weeks following the mishap, sufficient information emerged to lead several experienced marine industry hands (myself included) to draw credible preliminary conclusions concerning the proximate cause(s) of the sinking — conclusions that were derided by some as “premature” and possibly unfounded. While many in yachting and yachtbuilding counseled everyone to wait for the “official investigation(s)” to be completed.

At the time, we at FYBBO predicted that the “official” report would not be produced for at least a year and, more likely, would not be fully completed for two or more years. And I cautioned against allowing special industry interests time to influence the investigation in the direction of hanging primary responsibility for the loss on the Captain and the crew (who, by all reports, may have made some errors in judgement, but who acted in a completely courageous and professional manner, in trying to rescue those who were caught up in the vessel’s sinking). Now, somewhat more than two years later, I take no pleasure in reporting that the “official” investigation of the mishap is coming down exactly as I predicted during the first week following the incident.

The Italian government prosecutor is clearly protecting several powerful business interests involved against the dictates of common sense and the standards of intelligent risk management that were blatantly ignored by the naval architects of record, the classification society that approved the vessel’s plans, and the builder who constructed and later reportedly modified the vessel. For the full story, see the previously published articles listed below:

Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from For Yacht Builders, Buyers, and Owners.
Already have an account? Sign in
© 2026 Phil Friedman · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.